TWGHs Chow Yin Sum Primary School Internal Assessment Suspected of Leaking Hints; School Says Differences in Class Revision, No Re-exam Needed
🔥 Afraid of missing the latest open days, admissions information and application dates for primary and secondary schools across Hong Kong? Follow Goal-EDU.com now!
Internal assessments affect students' secondary school choices, and another school's assessment arrangements have sparked controversy. Parents told the media that the Primary 6 internal assessments held this month at Tung Wah Group of Hospitals Chow Yin Sum Primary School involved fairness issues, including an English teacher not having taught all assessed content, and a class's General Studies teacher allegedly "leaking hints" by pre-telling students the content of an extracurricular current affairs question. The school's notice to parents stated that there were "some differences in revision methods" among classes in General Studies, which may have indirectly affected the fairness of that part of the assessment, and that the current affairs questions would not be marked with deductions; the English assessment arrangements were not explained.
📚 Homework Not Distributed Three Days Before Exam; Some Content Not Taught
The parent said the Primary 6 English internal assessment was held on the 7th of this month. Three days before the exam, they discovered that the English teacher of the "Blue Group" had not distributed the English reading comprehension homework that was within the assessment scope, and enquired with the subject teacher, but the teacher at one point shifted the blame to students, saying the subject panel head had not distributed the homework. After retrieving the homework, they found the subject teacher had not taught all the assessment content, and part of the homework within the assessment scope was completely blank, i.e. not completed. The parent considered this would cause unfairness and confronted the principal, but was told that students had learned similar content and vocabulary in other teaching scopes, and students' marks would remain unchanged. The parent added that they had contacted other parents of classmates, and 18 students told their parents that the teacher had not taught all the assessment scope.
🗣️ General Studies Teacher Pre-announced Current Affairs Questions; Parent Quotes Principal as Saying Carelessly Mentioned in Class
The parent said that besides English, the handling of the General Studies examination held on the 10th of this month was also problematic. They understood that Class A students, after receiving teacher "hints," generally answered all three extracurricular current affairs questions correctly, with an average score as high as 90, while their daughter's class did not receive "hints." They quoted the principal as responding that the Class A General Studies teacher had only "carelessly mentioned" the extracurricular current affairs questions in class.
🏫 School Acknowledges Differences in Class Revision Methods Affecting Assessment Fairness
The school issued a notice to parents on the 18th, mentioning that it had "discovered that in the current affairs question section of the Primary 6 General Studies examination, there were some differences in classroom revision methods among classes, which may have indirectly affected the validity and fairness of that part of the assessment," and had immediately followed up and reported the matter to the Education Bureau and the sponsoring body. To balance the impact on assessment validity and fairness against the pressure of a re-examination on students, "after careful consideration and discussion, the school considers that not deducting marks for the current affairs question section is the most appropriate arrangement."
📋 Education Bureau: Has Required School to Follow Up Seriously and Explain Handling in Detail
The Education Bureau replied that it has required schools to strictly comply with the principles of fairness and justice in all school-based assessments and ensure assessment procedures are rigorous and proper. Upon learning of the incident, the Education Bureau immediately contacted the school to understand the situation, required the school to follow up seriously and give a detailed account of the handling work. The school has launched an investigation into the incident and will communicate with parents on its follow-up.