Chinese Paper 2 Proposition Writing "Grade Descriptors" Revised: Full Marks Reduced from 10 to 6
🔥 Afraid of missing the latest open days, admissions information and application dates for primary and secondary schools across Hong Kong? Follow Goal-EDU.com now!
The Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority (HKEAA) has announced a revision to the "Grade Descriptors" for Chinese Paper 2 Proposition Writing. From 2028, the full marks will be reduced from 10 to 6. The authority stressed that the assessment requirements remain unchanged and that the revision aims to help markers better utilise the entire grading range. Some teachers said the change makes it easier to distinguish the performance levels of "average candidates," but some may lose out on high scores.
📊 Grade Descriptors Full Marks Reduced from 10 to 6; Section B Full Marks Reduced from 100 to 60
The current marking method for the HKDSE Chinese Paper 2 Section B proposition writing assesses four major items: content, expression, structure, and punctuation and handwriting. Each has "grade descriptors" divided into upper grade, middle grade and lower grade, with each "grade" further subdivided into 3 to 4 grade steps, such as "upper-upper" and "upper-middle," with a full mark of 10. The four items carry different weightings; after weighting, Section B has a full mark of 100. The HKEAA recently held a Chinese Language teachers' meeting and announced that from 2028 the relevant "grade descriptors" will be revised: upper and lower grades will no longer be subdivided, the middle grade will retain 4 grade steps, and the full mark will be changed to 6; after weighting, Section B's full mark will be 60. In addition, under the current mechanism, candidates may receive bonus marks for no or few wrongly written characters; but the new mechanism will abolish the bonus system, although if there are 5 or more wrongly written characters, candidates can score at most 4 marks in the "punctuation and handwriting" item.
🗣️ HKEAA: Past Marking Overly Concentrated in "Middle Grade"; Streamlining Helps Markers
The HKEAA stressed that the assessment items, weightings and grade requirements remain unchanged in this revision. In reply to this newspaper, the authority further explained that past Section B marking was overly concentrated in the "middle grade," and this change is a "streamlining" arrangement to help markers appropriately use the scoring range; the new approach can also more effectively target wrongly written characters. The HKEAA revealed that it had already conducted research on adjusting the marking arrangements and had consulted the Chinese Language Subject Committee, and will provide training for teachers from the beginning of the year.
👨🏫 Teachers: New System Makes It Easier to Distinguish Average Candidates; Some May Lose Out on High Scores
Some teachers believe the new arrangement does not affect stronger candidates' ability to score high, saying frankly that "under the old system, only a minority scored above 8," so those reaching the "upper grade" level are all given full marks, with little impact. Under the new system, because the total score is reduced, differences become more obvious when scores are converted to "percentages," helping distinguish ability levels among average candidates.